Cage lifts vs goods lifts - the choices & differences
You’d be forgiven for thinking all goods lifts are the same, but they’re not… Whilst both help material movement and reduce manual handling risks there are some key differences ...
Below we’ll explain the difference between a cage lift and a goods lift in a structure. Whilst both help material movement and reduce manual handling risks there are some key differences. The cheapest isn’t always the best, so let’s find out...
What are these lifts?
A cage lift is typically a basic platform within an open-topped mesh enclosure that transports goods to secondary areas within a building such as stores, warehouses and workshops. A goods lift has a conventional lift car (meaning sides and a roof in addition to the platform) with a car gate (to protect the load) inside a fully enclosed structure.
Both lifts are typically used to move stock in cages, trolleys or on pallets. Goods lifts can also be supplied as goods attendant lifts, carrying up to 2 x trained attendants with the load.
An ideal solution if stairs are located elsewhere.
As both of these lifts are designed, as standard, not to carry people, there are no controls on the platform or in the car unlike a passenger carrying lift. Typically, the controls are at landings with call and send buttons.
What are the key differences between the two?
Machinery Directive 2006/42/EC
Machinery Directive 2006/42/EC plus additional safety features if carrying attendants incl. interior controls and communication system
The differences in a little more detail…
The majority of these lifts offer a flexible number of hourly working movements, however the starts per hour for cage lifts is usually more limited than a goods lift. This is a key consideration as you need to ensure your chosen workhorse is able to move at the pace you want - choose an under specified lift and you could face more breakdowns and repair bills. Another key difference is the lifting height, with cage lifts typically restricted to serving only 2 or 3 floors with limited travel capabilities.
Goods lifts are equipped with fully automatic call and send controls at each landing entrance. Cage lifts come with constant pressure control buttons (press and hold) meaning they take longer to move goods around (or you can’t get on with other jobs whilst sending the load).
When it comes to specifications, goods lifts come with a flexible design which can accommodate your low pit or headroom requirements. Their structure-supported frame makes the fitting fast and easy. On the other hand, the cage lift requires no pit just a small ramp, and they are freestanding/floor-mounted assemblies.
Standards and regulations
Both types of lifts comply with European and British legislation and are certified to The Machinery Directive 2006/42/EC. Both ranges are equipped with all the necessary safety features to ensure safe operation at all times. One great advantage of the goods lift over the mesh framed cage lift is that they come with fire-certified landing entrances - meaning only they can be used where fire separation between floors is required.
Both goods and cage lifts can be fitted almost anywhere in a building, moving safely and efficiently all kinds of stock in retail facilities, factories, warehouses, leisure venues and offices, in fact any back of house working environment..
However, if you are looking for a more robust lift that is fire rated, stands the test of time and ensures optimum safety and ease of use then a goods lift is the way to go.
Still unsure? No problem! Get in touch to speak to one of our lift experts or click here to download your FREE guide to goods lifts your question answered.
With nearly 50,000 installations across the UK and over 92,000 units on our service portfolio, Stannah offer a wide range of lift solutions and services to move people and goods. Take a look at our product range or simply get in touch.